Granite or Quartz: Which Is More Durable in the Kitchen?

Published by: Troy Granite | Delaware, Pittsburgh, Harrisburg

When choosing a new kitchen countertop, the most frequently asked question is: “Should I get granite or quartz?” Both look beautiful, both are high-quality — but which one truly lasts longer? With over 25 years of experience, we provide a clear answer to this question.

What is Granite?

Granite is a 100% natural stone formed deep within the earth over millions of years. Each slab is unique; its color, veining, and texture are completely one of a kind. This natural quality makes granite both an aesthetic and character-filled choice.

What is Quartz?

Quartz countertops, on the other hand, are engineered using about 90% natural quartz mineral combined with resins and pigments. In other words, they are semi-natural, semi-engineered. Their appearance is standard; each slab is nearly identical to the previous one.

Comparison in Terms of Durability

 

Hardness

Granite ranks between 6–7 on the Mohs scale of hardness. Quartz ranks above 7. From this perspective, quartz has a slightly harder surface and is a bit more resistant to scratching. However, this difference is barely noticeable in daily use; both stones are hard enough to withstand knife marks.

Heat Resistance

In this category, granite wins by a clear margin. Because it is a natural stone, it is highly heat-resistant; you can place a hot pot directly on it. Quartz, on the other hand, contains resin, so exposure to excessive heat can cause discoloration or cracking. For hot pots, it is strongly recommended to use a trivet on quartz countertops.

Stain and Liquid Resistance

Quartz has no pores, so it does not absorb liquids. Coffee, wine, olive oil — none of them penetrate the quartz surface. Granite, however, has natural pores and can stain over time if a surface sealer is not applied once a year. At Troy Granite, we fully explain this maintenance process for the granite you purchase.

Scratch Resistance

Both stones are extremely durable in daily use. However, the resin layer in quartz’s composition can show dull marks when subjected to very hard impacts or contact with sharp objects. Granite, thanks to its solid structure, is less susceptible to this type of surface damage.

Long-Term Appearance

With proper care, both maintain their beauty for decades. Granite may develop more “character” over time — a quality many homeowners love. Quartz retains its uniform appearance, just like on day one.

Maintenance Requirements

Which One Should You Choose?

Granite is the right choice if you:

• Use your countertop intensively while cooking hot meals

• Seek a different texture and aesthetic in every slab

• Want to bring the spirit of natural stone into your home

• Are looking for long-term value (granite adds value to your home)

Quartz is the right choice if you:

• Have children and a busy lifestyle (high stain resistance)

• Prefer a standard, predictable appearance

• Want minimal maintenance

• Seek consistent color and pattern

Troy Granite’s Verdict

Over 25 years, we have installed thousands of kitchen countertops. The honest answer is: both stones are high-quality and durable. The real difference lies in your usage habits and aesthetic expectations.

If you use your kitchen heavily and have a habit of placing hot pots directly on the counter, granite is the better choice for you. If you have small children and worry about all kinds of stains, quartz will put your mind at ease.

We recommend visiting our showroom to make the best decision. See and touch both granite and quartz samples in person, then decide.

 

Our Troy Granite Showrooms

Delaware (Newark): 711 Interchange Blvd. Newark, DE 19711 — (302) 292-1750
Pittsburgh: 484 Lowries Run Rd. Pittsburgh, PA 15237 — (412) 446-1060
Harrisburg (Camp Hill): 3617 Simpson Ferry Rd. Camp Hill, PA 17011 — (717) 918-3315

Call us today for a free in-home measurement and price quote.